Updated Nov 19, 2026· 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare five key lock boxes for home use, from portable dial boxes to wall-mount push-button models, and find the right fit for spare keys and guests.

A key lock box solves a simple problem that every household runs into sooner or later. Someone needs to get inside while you are away, and hiding a spare key under a mat or inside a fake rock is not a plan. A small metal box with a combination lock keeps that spare key in one known place, protected from weather and from casual discovery.

The five boxes below cover the main ways people use one at home: portable models for short-term needs, permanent wall-mount models for a fixed spot by the door, a slim box for a single spare, and a classic dial box with room for five keys.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Quick Answer

For most homes, the Master Lock 5400D is the simplest choice, with a portable shackle, a four-digit dial combination, and room for five keys. If you want a fixed spot by the door, pick the wall-mount Master Lock 5423D with its push-button code. For a single spare key in a slim box, the Kidde AccessPoint 001413 fits the job.

1. Master Lock 5400D Set Your Own Combination Portable Lock Box

The 5400D is the lock box most people picture when they think of this category, and it earned that position by being straightforward. A metal body holds up to five standard house keys, and a four-digit dial combination opens it. There are no batteries and no electronics, so there is nothing to charge.

Its portable design is the main appeal. The shackle fits over a doorknob, which makes it easy to set up for a weekend guest, a dog walker, or a contractor who needs access for a few days. When the visit is over, the box comes down and goes back in a drawer. A shutter door slides over the combination dials to keep out rain, dirt, and grime, and the vinyl-coated shackle helps prevent scratches on the door hardware.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Key capacity Up to 5 standard keys
Lock type Set-your-own 4-digit combination dial
Mount type Portable shackle, over-the-knob
Body width 3-1/4 in
Body material Metal
Weather protection Shutter door over dials
Shackle Vinyl coated
Warranty Limited lifetime warranty

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

Check price on Amazon

2. Master Lock 5422D Push Button Portable Lock Box

The 5422D takes the same portable idea as the 5400D and swaps the dials for push buttons. Instead of turning four dials to a code, you press a sequence of buttons, which some people find faster and easier to use in the dark or with cold hands. The combination is set by the owner.

This model holds up to five keys inside a metal body about 3-1/8 inches wide. The exterior measures roughly 6-7/8 inches high by 3-1/8 inches wide by 2-1/16 inches deep, while the interior measures about 3-1/2 inches high by 2-1/4 inches wide by 1 inch deep. That leaves room for several standard keys and a few access cards, which suits households that share access with family members, a house cleaner, or a trusted neighbor. A protective cover shields the button panel from weather, and the shackle lets the box hang from a doorknob or a fence.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Key capacity Up to 5 keys
Lock type Set-your-own push-button combination
Mount type Portable shackle
Body width 3-1/8 in
Exterior dimensions About 6-7/8 x 3-1/8 x 2-1/16 in
Interior dimensions About 3-1/2 x 2-1/4 x 1 in
Body material Metal
Weather protection Protective cover over button panel

3. Master Lock 5423D Push Button Wall Mount Lock Box

The 5423D is the wall-mount version of the push-button design, built for a permanent spot beside the front door. It screws to a wall or another fixed surface, so it stays in one place and cannot be carried off. The box becomes part of the house, and everyone who needs access knows exactly where to find it.

Its combination uses push buttons and can be set to a code of up to 12 letters, numbers, or a mix of both, which gives more code options than a four-digit dial. The box holds up to five house keys and access cards. A protective weather cover helps prevent freezing and jamming in cold or wet weather, and a molded bumper helps protect the surface it mounts against. Mounting hardware is included, and installation needs only a drill and a few minutes.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Key capacity Up to 5 house keys and access cards
Lock type Set-your-own push-button combination, up to 12 characters
Mount type Wall mount, permanent
Body width 3-1/8 in
Exterior dimensions About 4-5/8 x 3-1/8 x 2-1/16 in
Interior dimensions About 3-1/2 x 2-1/4 x 1 in
Body material Metal
Weather protection Protective weather cover
Mounting hardware Included

4. Kidde AccessPoint 001404 KeySafe Portable Push Button Lock Box

The Kidde AccessPoint 001404 is a compact portable lock box for households that only need to store a small number of keys. It holds up to three keys, which is enough for a front door key, a back door key, and a garage key. Its smaller size makes it less conspicuous on a doorknob than the larger five-key models.

The push-button combination is set by the owner and needs no batteries. The box hangs from a shackle, so it can be moved between doors or taken down when it is not needed. This model suits a simple use case: one spare key for one trusted person, or a second box for a side door while a bigger box covers the front door.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Key capacity Up to 3 keys
Lock type Push-button combination
Mount type Portable shackle
Brand Kidde
Model 001404
Color Clay
Power None, mechanical

5. Kidde AccessPoint 001014 KeySafe Original 5-Key Spin Dial Lock Box

The Kidde AccessPoint 001014 is a wall-mount lock box with a spin dial combination, the oldest style in this category and still one of the most reliable. The dial offers over 10,000 possible combinations, and the box holds up to five keys.

Because it mounts permanently to a flat surface, this box is a good choice for a household that wants a fixed access point and does not need to move the box around. The spin dial is fully mechanical, so there are no batteries to replace and no electronics to fail. The metal body is built to sit outdoors through rain and cold. A spin dial takes a little more care to use than push buttons, especially in low light, so it helps to know the combination by feel.

Key Specs

Spec Detail
Key capacity Up to 5 keys
Lock type Spin dial combination, over 10,000 possible codes
Mount type Wall mount, permanent
Brand Kidde
Model 001014
Color Titanium gray
Power None, mechanical

How to Choose

Start with how the box will be used. A portable box that hangs from a doorknob suits short-term access, such as a guest visit or a contractor job, because it can be removed when the need ends. A wall-mount box suits a permanent routine, such as a cleaner who needs access every week, because it stays in one known place.

Next, count the keys. Most boxes in this guide hold five keys, which covers a front door key, a back door key, and a few extras. If you only need one or two keys, a smaller box is easier to hide and lighter on the door. If you plan to store access cards alongside keys, check the interior depth first.

Then think about the combination. Push buttons are fast to use and easy to press in the dark, while dials are simple and proven but slower. A code with more characters gives more possible combinations, which matters if the box sits in a visible spot.

Finally, look at the mounting surface. A wall-mount box needs a flat, solid surface near the door and a drill for installation. A portable box needs a doorknob or a fence rail that the shackle can loop around. Measure the keys you plan to store first, since oversized keys may not fit in a standard interior.

Who Should Skip It

A key lock box is not the right answer for every household. If the only keys you need to share are car keys with large electronic fobs, a standard lock box interior is likely too small. If you live in a building where the front door is managed by a concierge or a shared entry system, a personal lock box may conflict with building rules, so check with the building manager first.

Anyone who wants the highest level of security should also think twice. A lock box is a convenience device, not a safe, and a determined person with tools and time can defeat one. It is best used for low-risk access, such as letting in a trusted neighbor or a family member.

FAQ

Can a key lock box be used outdoors in rain and snow?

Yes, the models in this guide are built for outdoor use, with metal bodies and covers that shield the combination mechanism from rain. A wall-mount box with a weather cover is the most protected option.

How often should the combination be changed?

Change the code whenever someone who knew it no longer needs access, such as after a guest leaves or a contractor finishes a job. For a household with regular visitors, changing the code every few months is a sensible routine.

Do lock boxes work with smart keys and key fobs?

Most standard lock boxes are sized for metal house keys and access cards, not for bulky electronic fobs. A large car key fob may not fit, so check the interior dimensions against the size of the fob first.

Is a wall-mount or portable lock box better for a rental property?

A portable box is usually the better choice for a rental, because it can be removed without leaving screw holes in the wall and moved between properties. A wall-mount box suits a home the owner lives in long term.

Final Verdict

For most homes, the Master Lock 5400D is the best starting point. It is simple, portable, holds five keys, and needs no batteries or installation. Households that want a fixed spot by the door should choose the Master Lock 5423D, which mounts permanently and offers a longer push-button code. The Master Lock 5422D is the portable push-button alternative for anyone who prefers buttons over dials. The Kidde 001404 covers the single-spare use case in a compact box, and the Kidde 001014 gives a proven spin-dial option for a permanent wall mount.

A
admin
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Key Lock Boxes for Home: 5 Secure…Check price on Amazon